Special Education Research Critique Essay

Special Education Research Critique Essay

GUIDE Rickson, D. J., & Watkins, W. G. (2003). Music remedy to promote prosocial behaviors in aggressive teenagers boys A pilot study. _Journal of Music Remedy, 40_(4), 283-301. PURPOSE The hypothesis of this research study was to determine if music therapy would help promote prosocial behaviours in extreme boys. These kinds of subjects will vary social, mental, and learning disorders. METHOD The subjects had been selected via a group of 88 young boys who have perceptive, social, and emotional failures. These boys were signed up for a special education facility in New Zealand. The students who began before Might 2000 after March 2001, which was 49 students, weren't included because of the likelihood of all of them leaving prior to the study was completed. This kind of left a remaining 39 students. These types of students were given the Child Patterns Checklist (CBCL) test. An overall total of 21 years old students were excluded due to lack of aggressiveness and already gone through musical technology therapy. Experts were left with 18 kids whose ages ranged from about 11 years and six months to 15 years and three months. These subject matter had an intense measure for the CBCL check. 12 of the boys had been already identified as having Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD) or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). With the 12, five had a dual diagnosis including Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD) or Perform Disorder (CD). Four a new general developmental delay and two had a head harm along with depression. About half of the kids were acquiring psychotropic medicine. They were at random assigned in to two music groups of six and a single control selection of six. One subject was suspended right after the therapy began. Another leave after a couple of minutes into a treatment. Also, an additional was hung from school after one period due to extreme disruptive and aggressive behavior. A total 15 students accomplished the treatment. Treatments was the individuals were placed into different music groups. In the music groups, the students would do different musical activities and express themselves through music. RESULTS There is an increase in bothersome and aggression in Group 1 . This really is a negative effect due to the treatment. Group 2 had not any changes in patterns. Group a few also got little to no change in their habit at university. AUTHOR’S CONCLUSION No significant statistical differences were identified after the treatment was completed. Because there was not a difference, there can be no definitive conclusion to get made by the writer. Some interpersonal workers would record improvement that were interesting and could cause further examine. They mentioned that the subjects were not as aggressive because they were prior to research study. Mcdougal would love to try to do another research but have this be based on a specific associated with the subject. USEFUL APPLICATIONS The usefulness on this treatment is extremely minimal. The results following the treatment was conducted had been negative or perhaps neutral overall. If I were to try and put into practice it to a classroom environment, I was not sure if it will be helpful in any way. CRITIQUE I feel like this examine not totally prepared or perhaps researched. The researchers would states their particular hypothesis, addressed the benefits, and the test size. However the treatment alone was not successful. The test size in this kind of treatment should have recently been bigger than just 15 pupils. The analysts could have gone and tested other universities or even general and senior high school.  A sample size of 12-15 subjects simply cannot represent 95 subjects. To summarize, this musical technology treatment research was not very well planned out.

Related Essays